Micro and Macro harms of Neoliberalism through the lens of violent and structural crime.


Day after day, the wider media issue reports on violent crimes, with a heavy focus on knife crime. It can be argued that the way in which violent crime is reported in the media focuses on pointing the blame on race, age, gender and the local communities in which they are immersed into. This blog aims to explore these narratives and to point out that the representation of violent crime, in the media is often misguided and does not truly reflect the reality as well as exploring central social structures and political philosophies which need to be held to account as well.

On Monday April 1st, 2019, BBC News published a headline on their website titled, - ‘Schools and NHS could be held accountable over Youth Crime’. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-47768631

The article discussed the ways in which schools and the NHS have ‘failed’ to prevent youth groups falling into violent crime. First, this article is blatant evidence that the wider media are not willing to accept that the Policy implemented by the Government has been destructive and a facilitator to these acts of violence, Secondly the article suggests that violent crime is wholly an issue relating to youth and race. Additionally, this is a clear example of where Neoliberalism and the values it possesses have been enshrined and not held accountable.

However, this blog aims to look beyond the statistics as they are presented to us in the news and wider media, and to examine the political philosophies and values which arguably have both directly and indirectly caused the levels of violence in society we are seeing now, and to examine the media’s role in these misrepresentations and inaccuracies.

Harvey (2005) interprets neoliberalism as a theory of liberation whereby individualism, autonomy, free markets and free trade is promoted and encouraged by the state through the lens of Capitalism.  Harvey (2005) also mentions that a neoliberal state is responsible for producing, maintaining and protecting this structural framework. It is argued by Thorsen and Lie (2006) that we are living in an ‘age of neoliberalism’ an age of autonomy and collective individualism. It can be argued in this case that we see a rise of social capital and aspirational values which are entrenched in our mainstream society and values. To contextualise this debate, it is interesting to explore the values of the education system. You are told that you can achieve this career, with this money that you will legitimately earn, and all will be well. However, it can be argued that these aspirational values have been made unattainable, especially for minority groups who face marginalisation and social exclusion both on the micro and macro levels.

According to Bakkali (2017), many ‘gangs’ are constructed and perceived through the lens of a moral panic.  Bakkali identifies that groups of collective individuals are formed as a method of having an identity and a way in which to gain higher levels of social capital, which have otherwise been made unattainable through legitimate means. However, Austerity and intrusive methods of policing have resulted in what Bakkali refers to as a ‘listening gap’. This means that there has been an ever-widening gap of understanding between the Police and these ‘gangs’. 

This displays a destructive cycle, starting right at the top of the chain at the hands of the Government. When the Conservatives came into power in 2010, they began a policy of cuts to public spending and investment. According to the Guardian (2018) https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/jul/31/slashing-youth-services-tories-betrayed-generation-labour-legal-requirement, the YMCA conducted research which found that overall spending on youth centres and service in England has dropped by £737 million (62%) since the 2010 Coalition. This has resulted in 600 youth centres closed, 3,500 youth workers out of work and 140,000 places for young people on youth projects disappearing. There is a common theme of deprivation within ‘working class’ communities in the UK. The ever-widening gap between the aspirations pushed by Neoliberalism and its rate of attainability could be argued a driving factor as to why we are seeing a rise in violence on the streets. These statistics show that the cuts made by Conservative policy has left a detrimental effect on these communities, yet the blame is still being placed on the Police, Schools and NHS, all of whom have faced extreme levels of cuts which have left them ill equipped to manage the rise in violent crime that we are seeing.

Hall and Wilson (2014) describe the way in which society is turning as ‘competitive individualism’. This is a reference to the rise of socio-economic inequalities and competition which arguably has stemmed from neoliberal values. This displays evidence to suggest that the rise in autonomous values have meant that individuals are becoming left behind through unattainability and social/economic marginalisation. The natural response to this is to form social alliances and unity through what we now construct as ‘gangs’ and gang behaviour.

It is Important to establish that exploring through the lens of serial killers, is an extreme and unique way of exploring and signifying wider trends of inter-personal violence within contemporary society. Lynes (2018) argues that the growth of liberal capitalism has had a role to play in the disintegration of socio-economic marginalised groups. Empirically, the result of what we have seen through the drive of marketization and capitalism is the formation of ‘non places’. Hall (2014). Lynes (2018) argues that this environment has allowed the rise of serial killers and violent offenders to surface through the perspective of social exclusion and marginalisation.

From this empirical evidence, the way in which we understand violence is not wholly its reality. There are deeply entrenched structural, social and philosophical issues which have been pushed to the frontline of our society but have not been held accountable. It can be argued that the Government and wider media do not want the impacts of neoliberalism and consumer capitalism to be blamed, as this would undermine and critique their policy. Instead it is a lot easier to point the blame at marginalised groups and to say this is their problem within their own communities. From empirical understanding, it can be argued that is makes sense as to why the media focus so heavily on constructions such as ‘black on black’ violence, and pinpointing increased responsibility and accountability onto Schools, the NHS and the Police, all of whom have faced detrimental cutbacks.



References: 



Bakkali Y (2018) life on road: symbolic struggle and the munpain, University of Sussex, Sussex.

Coughlan S (2019) Schools and NHS could be held accountable over Youth Crime, available at: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-47768631, date accessed: Friday 12th April 2019.

Hall S and Wilson D (2014)- New foundations: pseudo-pacification and special liberty as potential cornerstones for a multilevel theory of homicide and serial murder, European Journal of Criminology, Vol 1, pp651.

Harvey D (2005) - A brief history of Neoliberalism, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Lynes A, Kelly C, Uppal P (2018), Benjamin’s Flaneur and serial murder- an ultra-realist literary case study of Levi Bellfield- SAGE Journals, Vol 1 pp2,8,9.

 Smith C (2018), by slashing youth services, the Tories have betrayed a generation, Available at https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/jul/31/slashing-youth-services-tories-betrayed-generation-labour-legal-requirement date accessed: Monday 15th April 2019.

Thorsen E.D and Lie A (2006) ‘What is Neoliberalism, Research Gate. Vol 1, p1.

Treadwell J, Hall S, Winlow S (2012), shopocalypse now: consumer culture and the English Riots of 2011, British Journal of Criminology vol 1.






Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Know your enemy! The Fireworks that light up Cities and the flaws of the free market logic.

  To provide a summary of 2020, life has been pretty bleak.   The Corona Virus has rampaged through the World, with the UK as no exception as the death tolls that we know of have tragically reached nearly 60,000. ( https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/ ) whilst at the same time, millions of people in Britain have lost their jobs, families have broken down and many are already living in fear, loneliness and deteriorating mental health. In response to the ever growing risk to Public Health, the Government have introduced a series of measures which they believe will curb the spread of the virus and protecting those vulnerable as well as businesses who by the day are suffering economically. One rule in particular that is policy during the time of writing this piece is that people are not allowed to mix in households or indoor spaces in groups of more than six, unless all members of the party are from the same household. This measure at least means that there cannot be any Bonfire or fi...
Read more

The Road to 9/11 - A critical analysis

On the 11 th September 2001, two American airliners plummeted into the world trade centre towers, causing the towers to fall and over 3,000 lives to be lost. The series of events was described by Peter Dale Scott, author of ‘the road to 9/11, as being the worst case of homicide in all of America’s history. This statement cannot be argued against, there were over 3000 lives lost on the day of 9/11, which devastated families, communities and the world. However, there are many questions which can be raised as to the perpetrators of this act of terror, and what fuelled the attacks of 9/11 to take place in the first instance? Since the advent of 9/11, the world as we know it had drastically changed. The theory and practise of security both on a national and local level has arguably become tighter, we are now living in a society which favours suspicion, surveillance and monitoring of those who we believe pose a threat to our society and our way of life. These are usually presumptuous an...
Read more

BOOK REVIEW: TERRORIST HUNTER BY TAMER ELNOURY

Terrorist Hunter is written by a non-fictional FBI Agent called Tamer Elnoury. He narrates his incredibly moving story of his work undercover, posing as an Al-Qaeda sympathiser. His ultimate mission, to take down one of the biggest terrors plots the world has ever seen at the hands of Al-Qaeda. Throughout the book, as a reader, I learned about the regime and inside nature of an Al-Qaeda operative, actively capitalising on his misinterpretation of the teachings of Islam and the Quran.  I learned about the differences between American and Canadian undercover systems, for example how the Canadians would typically keep their own agents in the dark, whereas the US has a much higher rate of intel sharing amongst their most trusted political allies. They have the same motivation- to protect the Homeland, but they often differ in their approach. Tamer Elnoury also describes how the issue of national jurisdictions can cause complications for when the legal process begins once the terror...
Read more